
We’ve delved into all of the stats using the Squawka Comparison Matrix to produce a Liverpool vs Man Utd combined XI, ahead of this weekend’s Premier League showdown at Anfield.
Check the stats and see our eventual combined XI below. The players we’ve chosen to compare are from our predicted lineups for the match itself, using stats from their league seasons so far.

Goalkeeper: Alisson vs Senne Lammens
This is a fairly easy one, with Alisson dominating most of the relevant statistics on the Comparison Matrix. A key one is the clean sheets per 90 minutes statistic, given the fact Lammens is yet to keep one in the Premier League this season.
The Man Utd goalkeeper has made more saves per 90 minutes. However, Alisson leads the way when it comes to save percentage, goals conceded and ball recoveries. He also has the edge possession-wise, with a better tally for passes completed, passing accuracy, long passes completed and long pass accuracy.
Winner: Alisson
Right-back: Ronald Araujo vs Diogo Dalot
Araujo is still finding his feet in English football following his loan move from Barcelona. The Uruguay international boasts a better ground duel success rate and clearances made 90 per minutes than Dalot.
However, the Man Utd full-back is comfortably ahead of him with regards to chances created, crosses attempted and take-ons completed, as well as tackles made, ground duels won, interceptions and ball recoveries.
Winner: Diogo Dalot
Centre-backs: Jeremy Jacquet vs Virgil van Dijk vs Harry Maguire vs Lisandro Martinez
There was one clear choice when comparing these centre-backs, with the other just getting the nod.
Jacquet leads the way when it comes to tackles made, take-ons completed, ground duels won an success, and interceptions per 90 minutes.
When it comes to the other three, Van Dijk has comfortably made more clearances, while Martinez boasts the highest passing accuracy. Yet Maguire has the edge for tackles made, take-ons completed, ground duels won, interceptions and ball recoveries per 90, so he gets the nod.
Winners: Jeremy Jacquet and Harry Maguire
Left-back: Milos Kerkez vs Luke Shaw
Another fairly comfortable one, with Kerkez leading his counterpart for most of the statistics. Shaw has created more chances, made more tackles and interceptions per 90 minutes.
However, the Liverpool man has attempted more crosses and completed more take-ons, clearances and ball recoveries. He’s also won more ground duels, so gets the nod at left-back.
Winner: Milos Kerkez
Central midfielders: Alexis Mac Allister vs Dominik Szoboszlai vs Kobbie Mainoo vs Youri Tielemans
When comparing all four central midfielders, the evidence suggests Mainoo has been by far the most efficient, with more tackles made, take-ons completed, duels won, interceptions made and balls recovered than his counterparts per 90.
For the other place, it was a straight shootout between Tielemans and Mac Allister, with one leading the other in four statistics apiece. However, Tielemans has the edge, given he’s played just under 200 minutes more than the World Cup winner in the Premier League this season, and thus been more consistent over a slightly longer period.
Winners: Kobbie Mainoo and Youri Tielemans
Right-winger: Cody Gakpo vs Amad Diallo
Another close call, though the key difference was in the crucial numbers when it comes to attacking players.
Amad has registered more shots on target, completed take-ons and touches in the opposing box than Gakpo in the Premier League this season, but he’s still awaiting his first direct goal involvement.
That easily moves Gakpo in front, with the Liverpool man creating more chances, playing more through-balls and winning more fouls per 90 minutes.
Winner: Cody Gakpo
Attacking midfielder: Florian Wirtz vs Bruno Fernandes
Fernandes has created plenty of headlines this season, albeit most of them for behind-the-scenes behaviour as opposed to on-field credentials.
The Man Utd skipper has registered more goals, shots on target, through-balls, and a better passing accuracy per 90 minutes.
However, Wirtz has created more chances per 90, as well as bettering his counterpart for assists, take-ons completed, fouls won, ball recoveries and touches in the opposition box.
Winner: Florian Wirtz
Left-winger: Bradley Barcola vs Matheus Cunha
Barcola is still getting up to speed in the Premier League, following his big-money move from two-time reigning European champions Paris Saint-Germain. Nevertheless, he betters Cunha for touches in the opposing box, assists and completed take-ons per 90 minutes.
The Man Utd player is comfortably better, though, for goals, shots on target, chances created, through-balls, fouls won and take-on success per 90.
Winner: Matheus Cunha
Striker: Alexander Isak vs Bryan Mbeumo
Mbeumo has been utilised at the spearhead of Man Utd’s attack under Michael Carrick this season. A winger by trade, he’s created more chances and won more fouls per 90 minutes this season.
While Isak’s also been known to operate on the wing – notably completing more take-ons than Mbeumo – he’s more accustomed as an out-and-out striker. This is epitomised by his clear advantage for shots, goals, conversion rate and touches in opposing box per 90 minutes.
Winner: Alexander Isak
