Home » News » MLS » Columbus Crew vs Toronto FC: Predictions, Picks, Odds & Lineups

Columbus Crew vs Toronto FC: Predictions, Picks, Odds & Lineups

Columbus Crew vs Toronto FC predicted formations

Columbus Crew host Toronto FC at ScottsMiracle-Gro Field on Saturday, October 24 (3:30 PM ET / 2:30 PM CT / 12:30 PM PT).

Columbus Crew and Toronto FC both arrive with clean team news — no outs or suspensions flagged for either side — so Saturday’s teamsheet should lean heavily on the players already carrying the goals. Brais Méndez Portela leads the Crew’s attack with 5 goals and 24 chances created, with Taha Habroune (4 goals, 48 chances created) pulling the strings from midfield. For Toronto, Dániel Sallói (8 goals) and Joshua Sargent (7 goals) remain the senior forwards expected to lead the line.

Columbus sit 13th in the East on 32 points from 29 games, though they head into this one off the back of a 3-1 home win over Charlotte FC. Toronto are 10th on 36 points from 30 games and ahead of the Crew in the table, but a -9 goal difference and a 3-3 draw with Orlando City last time out point to problems at the back. Columbus’s attacking depth through Méndez Portela and Habroune, allied to home advantage, makes them the side better placed to find a result here.

Columbus Crew vs Toronto FC: Best Bets & Predictions

Columbus Crew look to climb the East against a leaky Toronto FC defence.

Columbus CrewTop pickColumbus's attack is carrying them at 13th in the East, with Brais Méndez Portela's 5 goals and 24 chances created outperforming their league position, while Toronto FC's -9 goal difference flags problems at the other end.
50%win prob.opening soon @ bet365
Columbus Crew 2-1 Toronto FCA 2-1 scoreline fits a Crew side finding goals through Méndez Portela and Taha Habroune (4 goals, 48 chances created) at home, against a Toronto defence already sitting at -9 on goal difference.
10%chanceopening soon @ bet365
YesBoth sides carry proven scorers — Dániel Sallói leads Toronto with 8 goals from 55 shots — making goals at both ends likely at ScottsMiracle-Gro Field.
60%chanceopening soon @ bet365
Over 2.5With Sallói, Joshua Sargent (7 goals) and Méndez Portela all among the goals this season, this fixture has more than enough attacking quality to clear 2.5.
59%chanceopening soon @ bet365
Anytime Goalscorer: Brais Méndez PortelaMéndez Portela has 5 goals this season and leads Columbus with 19 shots on target, giving him the clearest route to the scoresheet.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐chanceopening soon @ bet365

Our approach: we built this preview from Columbus Crew and Toronto FC's standings, recent form and underlying player numbers, with our Signal model locking in the projected scoreline and the headline picks below.

Back these with bet365Odds shown in American format; your local odds may vary.
Bet with bet365 → bet365 review

Odds correct at time of writing and shown in American format for illustration; your local odds may vary. 19+ (18+ in AB/MB/QC). Please play responsibly. ConnexOntario: 1-866-531-2600 (ON).

Season Form & Standings

Columbus Crew sit 13th in the East on 32 points from 29 games, while Toronto FC sit 10th on 36 points from 30. Both clubs remain inside touching distance of the playoff picture as the regular season winds down.

Eastern Conference

TeamPosGPWDLGFGAGDPts
Toronto FC1030812104655-936
Columbus Crew132995154447-332
Team News Predicted

Columbus Crew vs Toronto FC Predicted Lineups

Predicted XI — updated for the latest team news.

Columbus Crew

3-5-2
P. Schulte
M. Amundsen
S. Zawadzki
Steven Moreira
A. Zaroury
S. Rodriguez
T. Habroune
D. Chambost
M. Farsi
Josef Martinez
Brais Mendez

Toronto FC

4-4-2
L. Gavran
Matheus Pereira
N. Gomis
Z. Monlouis
K. Franklin
L. Morgan
J. Osorio
N. Dorsch
T. Corbeanu
D. Mihailovic
J. Sargent
    Squawka · Team News

    Potential Match-Winners

    • Brais Méndez Portela (Columbus Crew): The striker has 5 goals and 24 chances created, with 19 of his 38 shots on target — the clearest attacking threat on the pitch.
    • Taha Habroune (Columbus Crew): A midfield creator with 4 goals and a team-high 48 chances created, Habroune dictates the Crew’s attacking rhythm.
    • Dániel Sallói (Toronto FC): Toronto’s top scorer with 8 goals from 55 shots, Sallói remains their most direct route to goal.

    Recent Form

    Columbus Crew: L W W L W

    • 2026-10-15: Columbus Crew 3-1 Charlotte FC (W, home)
    • 2026-10-11: Orlando City 3-2 Columbus Crew (L, away)
    • 2026-09-28: Columbus Crew 2-1 Inter Miami (W, home)
    • 2026-09-20: CF Montreal 0-2 Columbus Crew (W, away)
    • 2026-09-13: Columbus Crew 0-1 New York Red Bulls (L, home)

    Columbus Crew’s form reads L, W, W, L, W across their last 5 matches, closing with a 3-1 home win over Charlotte FC on October 15.

    Toronto FC: L L L W D

    • 2026-10-15: Toronto FC 3-3 Orlando City (D, home)
    • 2026-10-10: Toronto FC 2-1 CF Montreal (W, home)
    • 2026-09-27: Nashville SC 2-0 Toronto FC (L, away)
    • 2026-09-20: St. Louis City SC 3-1 Toronto FC (L, away)
    • 2026-09-13: Orlando City 3-0 Toronto FC (L, away)

    Toronto FC’s form reads L, L, L, W, D across their last 5 matches, with a 3-3 draw against Orlando City their most recent result on October 15.

    Columbus Crew vs Toronto FC Prediction

    Expect Columbus Crew to see this one out 2-1. Brais Méndez Portela and Taha Habroune give the home side enough craft and end product to break down a Toronto defence already sitting at -9 on goal difference, while Dániel Sallói’s movement should be enough to get Toronto on the scoresheet without rescuing a point. Columbus sit 13th in the East on 32 points, Toronto 10th on 36 — both still inside the playoff picture as the margins at this end of the table stay tight.