Football Features

“This was his Vincent Kompany moment” – Full player ratings as Man City mow down Man Utd in EFL Cup semi-final

By Muhammad Butt

Published: 22:05, 6 January 2021 | Updated: 14:04, 11 September 2021

In an open and intense night of football, Manchester City beat Manchester United 0-2 to make their fourth-consecutive EFL Cup final.

Pep Guardiola’s men will now meet José Mourinho’s Spurs at Wembley. Meanwhile it’s yet another semi-final defeat for Ole Gunnar Solskjaer’s Manchester United (the second consecutive Manchester derby defeat in the EFL Cup semis).

Here’s how the players rated at Old Trafford:

Manchester United

Dean Henderson – 7 – Made some stunning saves to keep City at bay. Could do nothing about either City goal.

Aaron Wan-Bissaka – 6 – Defended his flank with authority as always. A perfect 5/5 tackles made him hard to get by but City still found a way to punish The Red Devils (and his poor clearance led to City’s second).

Victor Lindelof – 4 – A reasonably good performance spoiled by some classically Lindelof defending. The Swede failed to clear the cross for City’s opening goal despite being tasked to man the near-post. It was just miserable.

Harry Maguire – 7 – Some excellent defending to cover for the absolute disasters either side of him, but blotted his copybook by not reacting in to stop Stones from scoring.

Luke Shaw – 4 – Another disasterclass. Or a masterpiece in doing nothing. Created no attacking pressure, chose to overlap at all the wrong moments, lost John Stones for the opening goal and was constantly standing in the wrong position.

Scott McTominay – 6 – Worked hard but seemed confused as to his role, and given United weren’t parking the bus his skill as a roadblock went underused while his passing limitations became more obvious.

Fred – 7 – An decent performance from United’s Brazilian as he closed down and harried City’s men and moved the ball forward smartly.

Paul Pogba – 5 – Some fantastic runs forward didn’t amount to much of anything as The Red Devils faltered in the final third.

Bruno Fernandes – 5 – For once Fernandes looked unable to carry United on his shoulders. Full of bright ideas but the execution on his passes and shots was just off by a little bit, so nothing really happened when he was on the ball which is obviously strange. Needs a rest.

Marcus Rashford – 6 – Really good first-half, a bit slower second-half.

Anthony Martial – 4 – Awful performance. Constantly demanding the ball but doing nothing with it except for getting in people’s way and slowing the play down. Even managed to contribute to City’s second with an awful headed clearance. Very lucky to last the 90 minutes.


Mason Greenwood (for McTominay 75′) – 6 – Added some drive. Would have been nice to see him come on earlier and play centrally.

Donny van de Beek (for Fred 88′) – n/a – Came on way too late to do anything when he could have arguably started.

(Stake Not Returned on Free Bets). 18+ only. New UK Customers. Must bet £10 in total on 4+ legs, min odds 3/1 (4.0). £20 credited as Free Bets. Free Bets expire after 7 days, stake not returned. Full T&Cs apply.

18+ only. New Customers only. Bet £10* & Get £30* in Free Bets. Sign up, deposit between £5* and £10* to your account and bet365 will give you three times that value in Free Bets when you place qualifying bets to the same value and they are settled. Free Bets are paid as Bet Credits. Min odds/bet and payment method exclusions apply. Returns exclude Bet Credits stake. T&Cs, time limits & exclusions apply. *or currency equivalent.

18+ only. Place a min £10 bet on the Sportsbook on odds of min 1/2 (1.5), get £30 in Free Bets. Rewards valid for 30 days. SMS verification required. Only deposits via cards will qualify. T&Cs apply. Please Gamble Responsibly.

Enter code SBK10 to get your bonus. New UK, IE & Malta customers only. Min £10/€10 first deposit using Debit Card. Place a bet of £10 at min odds of 1.5 and get £10. Further £10 credited after 7 days. Full T&Cs apply. 18+.

Deposit £10 Get £10 in Free Bets T&Cs apply

New customer offer. 18+ only. New UK, IE & Malta customers only. Min £10/€10 first deposit using Debit Card. Place a bet of £10 at min odds of 1.5. Free bets expire in 90 days. Full T&Cs apply.

18+ only. New customers only. T&Cs apply.

Claim Here
Money back as a free bet if your first bet loses T&Cs apply

18+ only. New customers only. Sign up today with bonus code ‘Matchbook30’. Place your first bet, it if loses, we will refund your first bet stake as a free bet. The first bet must be placed within 7 days of registration and at odds of 1.8 or more. The max refund is a single £30 free bet and will be applied to your account with 72 hours of qualifying bet settlement. Please play responsibly. Full Terms Apply

18+ only. T&Cs apply.

Claim Here
Get a £30 Matched Free Bet if your first Acca loses + 50 bonus spins T&Cs apply

18+ only. *New UK customers only. Min Deposit: £5. Maximum Free Bet: £30. First bet on a Football or Horse Racing multiple with 3+ selections. Overall odds: 3.00 (2/1) or higher. Free Bets available upon settlement of the qualifying bet. This is offer is valid for 7 days from your new account being registered. 50 Bonus Spins credited on placement of qualifying Acca bet. 50x bonus wagering applies as do weighting requirements, bonus Spins only available on selected games and expires 7 days after being awarded. Debit card deposits only (exclusions apply). Full terms apply

18+ only. T&Cs apply. New customers only.

Claim Here

Manchester City

Zack Steffen – 6 – Wasn’t tested all that often by some wayward United shooting but performed well when he was.

Joao Cancelo – 7 – A bit sloppy with the ball in the first-half, committing unnecessary giveaways, but still ended up being a great source of penetrative play for City.

John Stones – 9 – Vincent Kompany made a habit of scoring big goals, particularly against Manchester United. John Stones had never looked worthy to inherit the big Belgian’s mantle as not only City’s best defender but also their leader. However he’s been on a fantastic run of late and he almost capped it all off tonight at Old Trafford.

The Englishman was simply sublime against United, rebuffing every attack and constantly denying The Red Devils anything. His night was capped off by two moments of excellence; one where he chased down, dispossessed and spun Paul Pogba like a top, and the other where he, y’know, scored the opening goal of the game.

This was his Vincent Kompany moment.

Ruben Dias – 9 – A relentlessly brilliant performance yet again from the rock solid defender. Nothing fancy, just got in the way and got the ball out of danger zones whenever United managed to penetrate. Has been transformative for the Manchester City defence and looks to have wonderful chemistry with Stones.

Oleksandr Zinchenko – 6 – Got given the run-around at the back but was always willing to work and provide width.

Fernandinho – 8 – Couldn’t contain United streaming in behind the City midfield in the way that he used to but did settle the game as a contest with a stunning second-half volley and was quite typically excellent with the ball.

Ilkay Gundogan – 8 – Another brilliant performance at the heart of midfield from the German midfielder as he helped Fernandinho control proceedings and direct traffic to the sides key playmakers.

Phil Foden – 7 – A quite simply sublime cross into the penalty area for the first City goal. Didn’t do too much else but that moment was so decisive as his cross made a mockery of the whole United defence.

Riyad Mahrez – 6 – A lively showing from Mahrez, constantly moving in behind. Pull a magnificent save out of Dean Henderson.

Kevin De Bruyne – 7 – No one created more chances than Kevin De Bruyne’s 2 and he nearly opened the scoring with a piledriver of a shot in the first-half. His movement was constantly creating trouble for United but none of his team-mates were on his level.

Raheem Sterling – 5 – Typically poor against Manchester United. One header aside he barely registered as a presence.


Rodri (for Mahrez 79′) – n/a – Came on late.