Baines vs Felllaini: Which Man United Transfer Target Is More Valuable To Everton?


Marouane Fellaini and Leighton Baines both had incredibly impressive seasons last year for the Toffees, and it’s naturally led to lots of speculation about their respective futures. Both players have drawn interest from a number of clubs around the world, and with Roberto Martinez conceding that either—and potentially both—players could leave Merseyside this summer according to the Daily Mirror, Everton clearly have a huge fight on their hands to ensure that both remain at Goodison Park for the new Premier League season.

However, while it might not be ideal, the reality is that Everton could well be forced into selling one player in order to keep the other for the year ahead.

So if it came to that, which star is worth keeping the most?

Given that Baines and Fellaini play very different positions, it is difficult to directly compare the two. Baines—a left-back—is going to make more tackles and clearances than Fellaini, and the central midfielder is going to have more shots on goal than the defender. Yet when we start to unpack their importance to Everton and their prowess and class in their respective positions, the standout choice becomes clear.

Baines. Leighton Baines.

Out of all defenders in Europe last season, Baines ranked first Total Performance Score. His attacking score was over 290 points clear of Eintracht Frankfurt’s Bastian Oczipka, and while that wasn’t quite matched by his total defensive score, he still did enough defensively to finish inside the top 10 for Defensive Score amongst Premier League defenders. Throughout the course of the season, Baines averaged a 79% success rate in his tackles and totalled 57 interceptions through the year as well.

save image

Playing every minute of Everton’s 2012-13 Premier League campaign, Baines created a staggering 116 goal-scoring chances—which was more than some of world football’s best playmakers, such as Ozil and Iniesta. In fact, it was more than any other player in Europe. As a result, it was little surprise to see that over 25% of Everton’s total chances created last year came down the left flank.

However, Baines’ brilliance shouldn’t necessarily take anything away from Fellaini. The robust Belgian international was the club’s leading goalscorer last season and finished with the same number of assists as Baines. While expected goalscorers Nikica Jelavic and Kevin Mirallas struggled to find the attacking potency that they’d promised, Fellaini was a revolution in central midfield and constantly caused havoc for opposing defences—something that Manchester United saw firsthand on the opening day of the year.

Yet despite all of this, there’s just no way that Fellaini is more important to the Toffees than Baines.

Everton’s best game of the season came in their 3-0 defeat of Swansea early in the season. And while it might have been Fellaini who popped up on the scoresheet that day, it was Baines who was awarded the Man of the Match thanks to his dynamic performance down the left wing. Squawka’s Individual Heat Map shows just how involved Baines was on the left wing while Fellaini was more scattered in his involvement.

save image

And while that’s just one match, it paints the season picture for both players and shows their respective importance—the Belgian might have scored the goals, but it was the Englishman who was the difference behind the scenes.

As such, it is more crucial that Everton keep Baines. He was the most creative player in all of Europe last year, and by far, the most important Toffees’ player as well.

The wait is over...

The free Squawka football app is here

Dan Talintyre
Dan Talintyre
Dan Talintyre is a full-time freelance journalist from Sydney, Australia with considerable experience writing on a number of sports and websites. His predominant focus (and love) has always remained football, with the tactics, statistics, and results of the beautiful game known to keep him awake for hours on end.
View Dan Talintyre's Posts »


Please consult these rules when commenting. These rules outline what is acceptable and unacceptable content on Squawka News. Note that these rules are subject to change at any time. Just like football.

See commenting rules
  1. Language

    Don't use swear words or profanity of any sort. Please refrain from insulting other users, everyone is entitled to their opinion and just because you shout the loudest, doesn't make you more correct or valid in your point of view. All insulting or offensive comments will be immediately removed.

  2. No libel or other abuse

    At no point should you be making comments which are:

    • defamatory, false or misleading;
    • insulting, threatening or abusive;
    • obscene or of a sexual nature;
    • offensive, racist, sexist, homophobic or discriminatory against any religions or other groups.

    We have an absolute zero tolerance policy on this. Football is the world's language.

  3. Report abuse

    If you see a comment not adhering to rules 1 & 2 please email and this comment will be reviewed by a member of the Squawka editorial team.

  4. No third party promotion

    This comment section is here to let football fans talk about football, not to allow people to sell or push products. Any comment found peddling a third party will be immediately reviewed.

  5. No linking or copyright infringement

    You must not insert links to websites or submit content which would be an infringement of copyright.

  6. Play the game/Respect the game

    Please respect these rules when commenting on Squawka News; people will disagree from time to time but please try to see each other's point of view before getting all worked up, that helps no one.